In other words, is there something that can be done so that ActivityPub gracefully degrades to something like RSS when implemented on static (or should we say “stateless”) sites?
I like the “stateless” characterization. The issue I see with degrading to RSS is that ActivityPub is primarily a push transport and RSS is a pull transport. Theoretically, servers could poll an AP outbox and that would be similar to RSS. However, I don’t know of any servers that do that and I don’t think that’s the behavior the AP spec authors intended.
As far as I can tell that requires Webmentions, and thus is not a static feature.
RSS provides the opposite of what I’m interested in. I want to allow people to interact with my site, not allow people to query my site for new content.
If I get you well @helge, you would like some mechanism, e.g., an HTML header, that would associate the static page with an ActivityPub actor.
Then one could imagine a lot of functionality:
- when the page is updated, a Note is sent by the actor
- people can comment on the page by posting to the actor’s inbox
- if the actor can keep ‘comments’, it can integrate it with the next static page compilation (and eventually goto 1…)
Somehow this makes me think that the static page could be available at an URL, and also in ERIS URN form. But this is probably another discussion
Yes, basically I want a way to provide a mechanism to generate a bidirectional link between “Static Pages” and “ActivityPub objects”. I actually don’t have an opinion which actor they would belong to.
The ActivityPub objects might be something like Proxy Objects. The big challenge here as with all proxying is feeding back the interactions with the ActivityPub object to the static site.
I’m not sure how relevant these are. I’ve had a curiosity about integrating fediverse into static sites myself.
I have stumbled upon two implementations of using the fediverse as a comment system on static site. They piggy back off of the Mastodon infrastructure. They may be of interest in this case:
You can also see them in use on the blogs themselves.
The cassidyjames blog says this about the comment system:
" I’ll leave a lot of the details for his post, but the super-simplified gist is:
- Write a blog post
- Post about it on Mastodon
- Grab the resulting post ID and plug it back into the static site
- The blog uses the Mastodon API client-side to fetch replies to the given post
- Those replies are spit out onto the page and styled"
welcome to SocialHub and thanks for your post. I think it puts what I want into perspective:
- Yes, one can probably use Mastodon to do what I want. I just feel like that Mastodon is a heavy solution …
- Second, if I want to have something like comment control. I will have to add this on top of Mastodon or wait for Mastodon to finally implement it. I would want comment control for what appears on my webpage.
I think I have a philosophical problem with it. I’d like my Fediverse applications to be small, instead of one monolith that more and more stuff gets added into.
I think pixels is the perfect Fediverse application in my eyes. It’s just like 200 lines of codes and does one thing.
Welcome @dannymate and thank you for your useful input!
Thanks for the welcome :). I hope my input is always useful. I’m not a particularly talkative person so you’ll rarely see me around. I also want to point out that this should be possible. Cactus Comments does something similar for Matrix.
So I think we’d need a seperate service (as is mentioned in the OP) to provide extra functionality to static sites. In this case lets focus on a comment system. The blogs I provided before piggy-backed off of Mastodon which isn’t specialised in any way for this task.
Annoyingly there’s a gap in my understanding for Static sites and comments as it isn’t something I’ve implemented before. I’m also not an expert on ActivityPub. But I’ll try my best to break down the requirements.
- We’ll want to avoid unecessary compilation so client-side comment fetching would be ideal. Therefore we don’t really want API calls from Fediverse to Blog. I know @how has voiced an opinion otherwise.
- An ID system that doesn’t require a Post Blog > Reference Blog in Fediverse > Get post ID > Add ID to Blog Post flow. Though it’s not a deal breaker.
- Ideally we can use any ActivityPub compatible software. That way we can use Mastodon or something more single-user like bugle? or something custom. This allows people to avoid having to spin up their own server for comments.
- We want to be able to control comments. For example, on the fediverse anyone can comment but only certain comments may be accepted onto the site. Or even an explicit approval first comment system.
I wonder if the comment control could be self-hosted seperately from a Mastodon/etc server.
I also found this: https://minipub.dev. It seems to utilise RSS.
Ideally we could rely on the relation between SocialHub account and Fediverse account to provide an AllowList, and have unknown accounts go into moderation. Most users here have put their Fediverse handle in their profile, and the ActivityPub plugin for Discourse now supports associating the two. So if we create a topic for each page, then replying to the topic (via Fediverse) updates the comments. Discourse has client-side integration of comments in this regard.
I must say that the original topic is about generic ways to add ActivityPub support for static sites, but we, especially I, have been talking about a specific use-case so far, related to the portal. (not that I’m fond of rockets either.)
The ideas & objectives section explains more about the project:
“Be able to share content onto matrix, from an entirely static setup (no dynamic server content generation, no database, just files and folders).”
“The purpose is not yet to have DM communication, but more public content from rooms, displayed via other matrix clients, without being able to participate in it.”
It makes me wonder if something like this is feasible with Matrix why couldn’t it be done with ActivityPub? Well maybe in the end it’ll serve to be impossible but it’s worth keeping an eye on.
I don’t know anything about the portal but I’m interested in the topic in general. So if this topic is actually intended for the one thing then I doubt I can contribute.
Referencing a toot by Dr. Freemo who got static site AP working, and it is live on flear.org.
[…] you can follow a user, and you get the accept back… it even sends the create push to followers when new articles come out, so you get it in your feed.
Check it out here: @flear
If anyone comments, stars, or reshares an article on the fedi it shows on the static website as comments on that site…
Basically all the core features you need are there and working. Feel free to use it
@randName notified me of a collection of resources they have been keeping track of that are relevant to this thread:
Hi, I am the dev on this project. I just wanted to let everyone know that I was adding features and the code was broken for a day or two (though I didnt realize it at first. The code has since been fixed along with a ton of new features. I am also working on making the code easier to reuse, once that is done I will make a separate post about it. In the meantime it seems to be fully working so feel free to snatch the code or follow the account:
Eventually I will move this into its own seperate repo as a boilerplate.
This is really cool thanks for sharing.
I see mention to Vercel and Firebase. Do they play a role in how ActivityPub is handled?
I’m wondering if something like this could be made as, say, a Hugo module.
Sadly the firebase and vercel components are where the activitypub magic happens in terms of being able to respond to followers, and sending out create notifications. However if you run it as a purely static site all of the non-dynamic functions should work (for example your outbox will still list the articles and people will see your content from the fediverse but they wont be able to follow you).
She is finally done and has a new home!
I made the code mostly configurable via a toml file and some environment variables. So you can spin up your own version of the site very quickly. I also added very detailed step by step instructions anyone can use to bring up a copy of this site for themselves.
I will make its own post on this shortly, but it should be ready to play with . I just wanted to follow up here since this is where it was first mentioned.
Here are some details:
The new website is https://fedipage.com
The new handle to follow it is @firstname.lastname@example.org
The source can be found here: v1.0.1 · Tags · Fedipage / Fedipage · GitLab
Detailed install instructions can be found in the README here: Fedipage / Fedipage · GitLab
Note the old page (https://flear.org) and it’s handle will stay up but it will solely post on the topics it was intended to cover (open-source in ham radio).
Some of the features in the release are as follows:
- Moved almost all site-specific stuff into configuration variables to make form easier install.
- Organized the layouts/partials so that it is very easy to update the the templates.
- Requires Vercel and Firebase for full ActivityPub support but will provide limited support as a purely static site as well. Limited support means the account can be seen, and its posts, but following wont be confirmed.
- Wrote detailed step-by-step install instructions to make it easy for everyone.
- Supports the following ActivityPub features:
- Following confirmation
- Notifications in your feed when new posts are made
- The various pages show content from the fediverse interacting with it like reboosts, likes, and even replies which show up as comments on the page.
- Tags are supported with a few options:
- Tags can be configured to automatically be added to every post.
- The tags added in the front-matter of a post can be added as fedivese tags. This can be set independently of any default tags.
- Tags can be rendered invisibly, not showing in the text of the post on the fediverse yet still contain the tag metadata for searches
- An ActivityPub alias can be set if you have other accounts across the fediverse. The alias can also allow you to migrate existing followers to the web page (untested, proceed at your own risk).
- Microblog side-panel can be configured to show content from your alias fediverse account.
- Multiple categories of blogs can be handled simultaniously and categorized and tagged independently.
- Front page is constructed from markdown and broken up into short codes. So the front page can be modified without touching the html.
FYI: Another project, a bridge implemented in Rust, targeting static sites:
A post was merged into an existing topic: About the Fedipage category
Another static website application by @mauve:
Discussed on HN here: Show HN: Fediverser Portal – Bring your subreddits to Lemmy | Hacker News
This is my attempt at helping those who are trying to ditch reddit but have not been satisfied with the content from Lemmy or haven’t been able to find the corresponding communities.
There are two sides to this project. The first one is that I have setup a Lemmy instance (alien.top) which is mirroring some of the reddit content from subreddits that I wanted to follow with the comments. The difference from most mirroring bots is that, instead of one single bot account mirroring all content, the system creates one account for each reddit user that is being mirrored.
The other part of this idea which I believe is more interesting: reddit users can take over their own mirrored bot account on this Lemmy instance. The instance itself does not use the regular registration process, but instead authenticates via Reddit OAuth. If you login through through the “Portal”, we can then grab your subscribed subreddits and (when it can) find the corresponding Lemmy communities and subscribe you to those automatically. At the moment there are not that Lemmy communities that are being mirrored because I’ve been the sole user, but hopefully if more people sign-up, it will help to create the network effects and more instance admins will be interested in hosting these “fediversed” communities.
All of the code is open source (GitHub - mushroomlabs/fediverser: A set of utilities to help bring content and users from legacy social media networks into the fediverse) and I’m more than willing to help people getting their own instances if they don’t want to use alien.top itself.
Questions and any type of feedback is always welcome!